Showing posts with label devil's advocate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label devil's advocate. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 4, 2010

Devil's Advocate #2



This episode of DA is a tad more cerebral.
-
DA #2: Existence and the Default Position

This topic may have links to my non-belief but leaving deities aside, I think it's a rather interesting topic of discussion. So here it goes.

I present to you one of my favourite logical arguments: Bertrand Russell's Teapot.


In a nutshell: If I told you that there was a teapot orbiting earth and further postulated that this teapot cannot be seen by any telescope known to mankind; would you believe me?

Most probably the answer would be no.

This line of logic is applied to the Loch Ness monster, Santa Claus, unicorns, "real" magic etc.

The question to be asked is Why? Why is it the most common answer to Russell's Teapot "No."?

It's probably because we are creatures of reason and logic. And that is why I argue that the default position for claiming the existence of something is one of non-existence.

Meaning, we do not believe schizophrenics when they claim that they are hearing voices in the night without evidence. Those voices, do not exist until proven.

This same reasoning applies to the criminally charged. As the old adage goes: Innocent until proven guilty.

One reason for this line of thought is the fact that it is illogical and impossible to prove a negative (of course in the context of absolutes, universality and objectivity).


For example, if I claim that there are unicorns in the world, it is my onus to prove it.

It is illogical for me to request OTHERS to prove that there are no unicorns to make the unicorns' existence legitimate.

How can you go about proving that there are NO unicorns? You can't.

But does that mean they exist? Of course not. It is the person who makes the claim who is responsible for justifying it.

However, this proving non-existence can be done under special limitations of course, for example, if I told you that there was a unicorn under my bed, you could very well prove that there wasn't one by looking under the bed.

But when it comes to the universal, absolute existence of anything, it is those who make the claim that have the responsibility in providing evidence for it to make the 'something' objectively existent.

I am obligated to present you substantial evidence for the existence of unicorns for them to be considered to have existed. Otherwise, I'm just the regular nutty, no different from those that believe vampires exist because Stephanie Meyer said so.

-

Agreed? Disagreed? Lemme know.

Sunday, July 25, 2010

Devil's Advocate #1


I have decided to attempt intelligent discussion; occasioning the trivial and absurd. I call this attempt the Devil's Advocate series!

This is where I play devil's advocate and take points of view and challenge them.

I hope it won't be a one way thing. Just comment and we can continue the discussion!

_

If you've been watching Astro, you would have come across a lame attempt at a PSA regarding the abandonment of babies, or the throwing away of infants to be more blunt.

The attempt is one of a karoke style, let's get all the celebs we can find and have them sing this emo-ish it's going to crescendo at the end with a strong solo by a woman in the middle type tune.

Now, I am against the throwing away of babies. Hell yes. I think people who do this are murderers and should be locked up (or if they are suffering from post natal depression, a shorter sentence with psychological help).

That aside, just days after I watched the PSA for the n-th time, I heard on the radio that a local government does not agree that sex education shou
ld be taught in schools. Their reasoning behind this: It may encourage underage, pre-marital sex which may lead to a proliferation of infanticide. (not ad verbatim)

So!

Devil's Advocate #1: Sex education in schools

It must be taught! It's illogical to say that by NOT telling teenagers about the effectiveness of contraceptives and propagate the notion of "abstinence is the ONLY way" - that the number of teen pregnancies will drop. There is actually research that proves the contrary:

"Experts from the American Public Health Associatio
n and U.S. Institute of Medicine testified that scientific studies have not found that abstinence-only teaching works to cut pregnancies, sexually transmitted diseases or the age when sexual activity begins." (Reuters)

However, there IS research that shows CONDOMS FUCKING WORK.

We're not really taught sex education here, and that whole chart on contraceptives in the bio text books is hardly counted as sex education.

Funnily enough, contraception is taught in NS. When I went, they showed us how to put on a condom on a banana, or a cucumber, I forget.

I say teach both. Contraception AND abstinence. Show us research, give us proof. Then let US decide. Stop shoving dogma down students' throats (haha double entendre).

People are going to have sex. And when they do, equipped with the knowledge that contraceptives can prevent pregnancies and STDs, maybe THEN, infanticide rates will fall.

Don't just sing it with "peshen" and think you're going to enlighten hormone pumped sexual beings.

-

I welcome feedback for further discussion!

Short ones, long ones (haha double entendre. again!), feedback of any kind is appreciated.